MetLife Pet Insurance: Best for Multi-Pet Families

Anyone who's sat in a vet's waiting room with a sick dog or a hurting cat knows the feeling: you'd pay anything to make them better — and then the estimate lands. For homes with more than one animal, that worry multiplies with every wagging tail and curious paw. Pet insurance exists to take the financial sting out of those moments, and for families with a full house, MetLife Pet Insurance has built its reputation on protecting the whole crew without the headache of juggling separate policies.

MetLife is one of the most recognized names in insurance, and its pet division brings that scale to your four-legged family. MetLife Pet was named a Pet Insurance of the Year winner at the 2024 Pet Independent Innovation Awards, and it's a member of the North American Pet Health Insurance Association (NAPHIA). Its policies are underwritten by Metropolitan General Insurance Company. In plain terms: it's a well-backed plan from a company that isn't going anywhere.

One Policy for Your Whole Pack

This is where MetLife stands apart. Most insurers make you open a separate policy — and pay a separate deductible — for every pet you own. MetLife lets you cover up to three pets on a single family plan. Even better, those pets share one deductible and one annual benefit limit, so your covered vet bills add up together and you hit your deductible faster. You can mix cats and dogs on the same plan, too.

For a two- or three-pet household, that's one premium to budget for, one renewal date to remember, and one place to file every claim — instead of a folder full of policies that all renew on different days.

Get a Free Quote →

No Upper Age Limit: A Rare Win for Senior Pets

Plenty of insurers quietly slam the door on older animals, refusing to enroll a pet once it passes a certain age. MetLife doesn't. There's no upper age limit to enroll, so the 11-year-old Lab or the senior tabby you've loved for a decade can still get a policy. (Coverage options can vary depending on your pet's age, so it's worth pulling a quote to see exactly what's available for yours.)

MetLife also skips breed restrictions entirely — purebred or mixed, pint-sized or giant, your pet can be covered. If you've ever been turned away elsewhere because of your pet's age, this is the detail that matters most.

Coverage You Can Shape Around Your Budget

MetLife's accident-and-illness plans cover the expensive things pet parents dread: cancer treatment, heart disease, surgeries, hospitalization, diagnostics, emergency care, and exam fees. You can also add an optional Preventive Care plan for routine costs like vaccinations, flea and tick prevention, and spaying or neutering.

What makes it work for real budgets is the flexibility. You choose your reimbursement rate — up to 90% of the bill back — along with your deductible (as low as $0) and your annual benefit limit (up to $25,000, with an unlimited option available in some areas). Dial those up or down and the premium moves with them. There are no per-incident caps, either: covered claims count toward your annual limit rather than a separate ceiling for each injury or illness. And because there's no provider network, you can use any licensed vet in the U.S. — including the one your pets already trust.

Plans start as low as $7/month for cats and $16/month for dogs, though your actual rate depends on your pet's age, breed, location, and the coverage you choose.

Pet Insurance That's Actually Easy to Use

Signing up is refreshingly low-friction — there's no required vet exam or medical records to enroll. Accident coverage and any Preventive Care benefits kick in at midnight after you sign up (no waiting period), while illness coverage begins after a 14-day wait.

When something does happen, you pay your vet, snap a photo of the bill, and submit a claim through the MetLife Pet app. MetLife says approved claims are typically reimbursed within about five days, paid out by Zelle, PayPal, or check. Policyholders also get free 24/7 access to a vet chat (provided by AskVet) for those 2 a.m. "is this an emergency?" moments.

A Few Things to Know Before You Enroll

Like nearly every pet insurer, MetLife doesn't cover pre-existing conditions — anything your pet showed signs of before coverage started or during a waiting period. Illness coverage carries that 14-day waiting period, and some coverage options may be limited based on your pet's age. None of this is unusual for the industry, but it's worth understanding up front — and a good reason to enroll while your pet is healthy rather than waiting until a problem appears.

The Bottom Line

For a home with more than one pet — or an older companion who's been turned away elsewhere — MetLife Pet Insurance is one of the most accommodating options out there. One policy can protect the whole pack, there's no age ceiling to enroll, and you can tailor the coverage to fit your budget. See what it would cost to protect your crew.

Ads by Money. We may be compensated if you click this ad.Ad

Get the care your pet needs with a Pet Insurance Policy

Embrace can help you fetch a great plan and for your four-legged friend. Select your state to get a free quote today!

View Plans

Advertiser Disclosures:

*Coverage is subject to restrictions, exclusions, and limitations, and applications are subject to underwriting. Reimbursement options are 50%, 70%, 80%, and 90%. Deductible and annual limit options vary; an unlimited annual benefit option is subject to availability. Coverage options may be limited for certain ages. Pre-existing conditions are not covered. Accident and optional Preventive Care coverage begins at midnight EST on the policy's effective day; illness coverage begins 14 days after the effective day. Sample starting prices are based on select plans and coverages; actual rates vary by pet age, breed, location, deductible, reimbursement rate, and annual limit. Pet insurance is issued by Metropolitan General Insurance Company. "Pet Insurance of the Year" — 2024 Pet Independent Innovation Awards.