7 Best Car Insurance Companies in Florida

To find the best car insurers in Florida, Money considered well-known companies offering affordable coverage, discounts and other features to help you save.

Florida law requires drivers to have a minimum auto liability insurance of $10,000 for PIP/ PDL, but our list includes reasonably-priced coverage options that exceed these limits.

The best Florida car insurers reviewed (alphabetically)

Allstate Florida car insurance

Allstate is the top car insurance provider for the state of Florida for overall customer satisfaction based on J.D. Power's 2020 U.S. Car Insurance Satisfaction Study.

Lower-risk drivers pay an average rate of $1,485 for minimum coverage and $2,359 for full coverage with Allstate. Meanwhile, higher-risk drivers could pay between $3,452 and $4,884.

While Allstate’s premiums for higher-risk drivers may seem high, the company offers exclusive rewards for safe driving. For example, you’re entitled to a “safe driving bonus” check for every six months you're accident-free and can qualify for accident forgiveness even if you're a high-risk driver.

Additional coverage

• Some additional coverage options from Allstate include:
• Accident forgiveness
• Medical payments
• Sound system insurance
• Roadside assistance
• Personal umbrella policy
• Rental reimbursement
• Ride for Hire insurance (for Rideshare drivers)

Resources and ways to save

• Discounts: Safety equipment, teen driving, bundling policies, new car, safe driving and payment discounts.
• Drivewise App: Get a discount on your car insurance rate for save driving.
• Milewise App: Get a lower premium based on how much and how well you drive.

Amica Mutual Florida car insurance

While Amica Mutual isn’t featured in J.D. Power's 2020 U.S. Car Insurance Satisfaction Study for the state of Florida, the company has ranked as the top car insurer in New England for eight consecutive years.

Low-risk drivers can expect to pay between $1,092 for minimum coverage and $1,440 for maximum coverage with Amica. Meanwhile, higher-risk drivers could expect to pay between $4,827 and $6,036.

While these premiums aren’t among the highest on our list, higher-risk drivers should keep in mind that Amica Mutual’s basic coverage option surpasses the state minimum liability requirement and includes rental reimbursement. Additionally, Amica's Advantage Points program lets drivers earn points that they can use to lower their deductibles.

Additional coverage

Other Amica Mutual coverage options include:

• Medical payments
• Auto/loan lease coverage
• Credit monitoring
• Roadside assistance
• Uninsured motorist property damage
• Full glass coverage

Resources and ways to save

• Accident Forgiveness/ Good Driving Rewards: Earn advantage points to reduce or eliminate your deductible. Waive the auto accident surcharge.
• Discounts: Teen driver, bundling policies, loyalty, safe driving and payment discounts.
• Amica Mutual Car Connect: Get quotes for car models you’re looking to purchase.
• Amica Mutual Contractor Connect: Access to Amica’s network of home remodeling contractors.

Farmers Florida car insurance

Farmers wasn't included in J.D. Power's 2020 U.S. Car Insurance Satisfaction Study for Florida, yet the insurer was featured in most other states scoring just below the regional average for overall customer satisfaction.

Low-risk drivers in the state of Florida can expect to pay between $1,001 for minimum coverage and $1,657 for maximum coverage with Farmers. On the other hand, high-risk drivers could pay between $10,276 and $10,819, respectively.

Although Farmers offers perks like rental reimbursement, it charges some of the highest premiums out of all the companies on our list, both for high- and low-risk drivers. To help customers reduce their premiums, Farmers offers multiple discounts such as a Senior Driver discount for people over 55 as well as discounts for teachers, nurses and other healthcare workers.

Additional coverage

Other coverage options from Farmers are:

• Medical payments
• Towing and roadside service
• Rental car reimbursement (30 days)
• Rideshare insurance
• Loss of Use
• Customized equipment
• Personal umbrella
• Glass deductible buyback ($100 deductible)
• Full windshield and glass coverage
• Original equipment manufacturer
• New car replacement
• Accident forgiveness

Resources and ways to save

• Discounts: For insuring multiple vehicles, sharing a family vehicle, bundling policies, being a good student or a student away from home, taking a defensive driving course, owning a vehicle that uses alternative fuel, driving safely and having vehicle safety features.
• Classic & Collector Car Insurance: You can add roadside assistance, up to $750 in spare parts coverage, and full windshield and safety glass coverage to your policy.
• Accident Forgiveness: Accident forgiveness is available at an additional cost and applies to one car accident every three years.
• Signal App: Save up to 15% on premiums for good driving behavior.

Geico Florida car insurance

Geico received an above-average rating in J.D. Power's 2020 U.S. Car Insurance Satisfaction Study for the state of Florida, coming in second for overall customer satisfaction.

As for premiums, low-risk customers can expect to pay approximately $849 for car insurance with Geico. In contrast, high-risk Geico clients could expect to pay up to $5,311.

Geico sells no-frills policies covering just the basics at prices nearing the higher end of the spectrum. Nevertheless, it offers a broad range of discounts to make its policies more affordable, including exclusive savings opportunities for active-duty military members and veterans.

Additional coverage

While Geico only offers one customizable policy option, you can always purchase additional coverage, such as:

• Medical payments
• Personal injury protection
• Uninsured motorist coverage
• Underinsured motorist coverage
• Emergency road service
• Rental reimbursement
• Mechanical breakdown insurance

Resources and ways to save

• Discounts: Safe driving, military and federal employee discounts, loyalty, safety equipment and driver's education.
• Geico Mobile App: Easy Photo Estimate feature, access to insurance ID cards and 24/7 roadside assistance, among other tools.
• DriveEasy App: Get a premium discount for safe driving.
• Federal Employees Program: Eligible clients can receive exclusive discounts or scholarships.
• Tools: Geico Driving and Safety Tips Blog, a local gas prices comparison tool, car buying resources, a parking locator app and a coverage calculator.

Liberty Mutual Florida car insurance

Liberty Mutual received an above-average customer satisfaction score in J.D. Power's most recent Car Insurance Satisfaction Study for Florida.

Low-risk Liberty Mutual customers in this state can expect to pay between $431 for minimum coverage and $1,075 maximum coverage, while higher-risk drivers could pay between $3,251 and $4,987. To help customers choose the right coverage limits and premiums, Liberty Mutual's website offers an easy-to-use coverage calculator.

While lower-risk drivers may benefit from Liberty Mutual’s competitive premiums, this is not the case for higher-risk drivers. This last group will find that, out of the companies on this list, Liberty Mutual charges some of the highest premiums to drivers who don't own their home and vehicle or live in highly populated areas, among other factors.

Additional coverage

Liberty Mutual offers a variety of additional car insurance coverage options, including:

• Medical payments
• Rental reimbursement
• Roadside assistance
• Original parts replacement
• Mexico car insurance
• Gap coverage
• Lifetime repair guarantee
• New car replacement
• Better car replacement
• Coverage for teachers

Resources and ways to save

• Discounts: Online purchase, bundling policies, early shoppers, student discounts, military, safety features, alternative energy, safe driving and paperless policy discounts.
• Liberty Mutual Deductible Fund: Customers with collision coverage pay extra premium to reduce their deductibles by $100 each year.
• RightTrack: Get rewarded for good driving and save up to 30% on your policy.
• Tools: Car insurance 101 blog and car buying blog.

Progressive Florida car insurance

While Progressive scored just below the regional average on J.D. Power's 2020 U.S. Car Insurance Satisfaction Study for Florida, it was among the top five auto insurers in the state.

Low-risk Progressive customers in the state of Florida can expect to pay between $395 for minimum coverage and $903 for maximum coverage. By contrast, higher-risk drivers could pay between $1,756 and $3,977.

Out of all the insurers on this list, Progressive charges some of the lowest rates in Florida. While it's true the company offers few additional coverage options for the price, its Name Your Price Tool is among its most attractive features, allowing Progressive customers to purchase car insurance based on what they can afford and their state's minimum liability coverage requirements.

Additional Coverage

Progressive offers a wide variety of coverage options you can add to your car insurance policy, including:

• Uninsured bodily injury
• Underinsured bodily injury
• Uninsured motorist property damage
• Underinsured motorist property damage
• Medical Payments
• Loan/ lease payoff (gap insurance)
• Roadside assistance
• Rideshare coverage
• Rental car reimbursement ($40 - $60 per day)
• Custom parts and equipment coverage ($5,000 limit)

Resources and ways to save

• Deductible savings bank: Subtract $50 from your collision and comprehensive deductible for every claim-free policy period; policy periods last 6 months.
• Tools: A car insurance calculator.
• Name Your Price Tool: Share your budget with Progressive and receive policy options within that price range.
• Discounts: For bundling policies, continuous coverage, safe driving, being a good student or students away from home, and several different payment discounts.
• Snapshot Program: Personalizes your auto insurance rate based on how you drive.

State Farm Florida car insurance

State Farm is featured in J.D. Power's 2020 U.S. Car Insurance Satisfaction Study for Florida, ranking just under the regional average for overall customer satisfaction.

Lower-risk State Farm customers could pay between $276 and $564, depending on the coverage limits selected, while higher-risk drivers could pay between $2,527 and $3,196 for maximum coverage.

State Farm’s premiums are the cheapest out of all the companies on our list, both for high- and low-risk Florida drivers. It also offers some appealing coverage options for those who collect antique or vintage cars.

Additional coverage

State Farm also offers the following additional coverage options:

• Teen driver coverage
• Rental car coverage
• Sports car coverage
• Classic & antique vehicle coverage
• Commercial auto coverage
• Rideshare insurance
• Car rental reimbursement
• Medical payments
• Emergency roadside assistance

State Farm Auto Resources

• Discounts: For bundled policies, good students and students away from home, being accident-free, taking a defensive driving course and having vehicles with safety features.
• Tools: Auto insurance tips & resources blog, a repair facility locator tool and Simple Insights articles on insurance, savings and more.
• Drive Safe & Save App: Save up to 30% on car insurance by driving safely.

How to get the cheapest car insurance in Florida

The best ways to save money on car insurance are pretty universal, whether you live in Florida or elsewhere in the continental U.S.

Here are a few of them:

Shop around

Comparison shopping is one of the best ways to ensure you're not paying more than you have to for the car insurance coverage you need.

Insurance companies price risk based on their own particular guidelines, so you may be quoted very different prices depending on the insurer, your personal details, and the coverage types and limits you select.

Another reason to shop for car insurance quotes is to find discounts and savings opportunities for which you may qualify. Keep in mind that not all discounts are available in all states and that discount amounts may vary by company.

Increase your deductible

The deductible is what you pay out of pocket before your insurer covers a percentage of your claim.

On average, a deductible can cost anywhere from $500 to $1,000, although you may find some coverage options don't require a deductible at all.

By paying a higher deductible, you take on more financial responsibility for a claim. The result is a decreased risk of incurring an insured loss for the insurer and a lower premium for you.

If you opt for a lower deductible, your premium will likely be higher. However, only choose a high deductible if you're sure it's an amount you can comfortably afford.

Ditch extra coverage for older vehicles

If you have an older car, consider ditching collision and comprehensive coverage for that vehicle.

According to the Insurance Information Institute, if your older car is worth less than 10 times the premium you're paying for it, these two coverages may not be worth the cost.

However, if your older vehicle is a classic or collectible, consider getting extra coverage specifically geared for these types of vehicles.

Improve your credit score

Many insurers use credit information to determine car insurance premiums. That's because research has shown that people with poor credit are more likely to be involved in an accident.

Credit scoring models differ, but generally speaking, you're considered to have good credit when your credit score is above 670.

Check out your free credit reports at annualcreditreport.com to make sure there are no incorrect or fraudulent items in your reports that could be affecting your credit scores.

Look for cars with the latest safety features

If or when you're in the market for a new car, consider the value of having a model with good safety features.

Many insurers offer discounts for vehicles with anti-lock brakes, stability control, air bags and other features that will keep you and your passengers safe and decrease your risk of being involved in an expensive collision.

Bundle and save

Bundling insurance is an easy way to cut down the cost of your premiums. Many insurers offer discounts if you bundle your home insurance and car insurance, for instance.

At first glance, this can be a straightforward solution to simplify your monthly payments. However, bundling insurance may not always be the cheapest option in certain cases. If you shop around, you may find that you’ll save more if you have policies with separate insurers.

Before putting all your eggs in one basket, do your homework and calculate your savings before switching over to a single provider. Also note that bundling, as with many discounts, may be limited to certain states, depending on the insurer.

Consider telematics insurance

Telematics or usage-based insurance (UBI) employs technology to customize your premiums based on how well or how much you drive. Many insurers offer discounts for signing up for telematics programs plus additional savings based on good driving behavior.

Policyholders interested in these programs can sign up by downloading an app on their mobile phones and taking a test drive. But be warned, while this can yield significant savings for safe drivers, it could also increase your rates if you're not among this group.

Methodology

Money’s Best Car Insurance Companies in Florida include a variety of insurers licensed in most states that offer comprehensive yet affordable coverage options for every kind of driver.

To evaluate each company's overall customer satisfaction pertaining to the state of Florida, we referenced J.D. Powers 2020 U.S. Auto Insurance satisfaction study, which ranks insurers based on factors such as billing process and policy information, claims, interaction, policy offerings and price.

Finally, we gathered rate quotes from each company based on two customer profiles: one high-risk driver and one low-risk driver.

Quotes obtained for the purpose of this research exceed the minimum liability insurance requirements in Florida.

Consumer profiles

Insurance underwriters determine premiums based on demographic and statistical information linked to higher or lower risks of incurring losses. While risk factors vary from one insurer to the next, some key factors are common amongst insurers.

Higher-risk drivers are those who have bad credit, a spotty payment history or violations such as DUIs on their driving records.

However, a clean driving record does not a low-risk driver make. There are other factors that determine your risk level and, subsequently, your car insurance premium.

These include:

• Gender
• Age
• Marital Status
• Zip code
• Driving history
• If you own or rent your home
• Mileage
• Previous claims
• Vehicle type
• Vehicle condition (age and value)

To obtain quotes from the auto insurers on this list, Money’s team constructed two client profiles, one considered lower-risk and another considered higher-risk based on personally identifiable information linked to higher and lower likelihoods of incurring losses.

While credit and past traffic infractions such as speeding tickets influence premiums, we omitted these factors from our customer profiles.

Coverage amounts

The car insurance quotes collected for Money’s Best Car Insurers in Florida are for coverage amounts that exceed the state’s minimum liability insurance requirements of $10,000 in personal injury protection (PIP) and property damage liability (PDL) coverage.

The coverage breakdown is as follows:

• $50,000 in Property Damage Liability
• $100,000 per person and $300,000 per accident in Bodily Injury Liability
• $100,000 per person and $300,000 per accident in Uninsured/ Underinsured Motorist protection
• Collision coverage with a $1,000 deductible
• Comprehensive coverage with a $1,000 deductible

As we obtained car insurance quotes, we found that most insurers offer three coverage tiers, from basic to comprehensive. While some basic tiers provided coverage that often exceeded Florida's minimum liability insurance requirements, each coverage package was customizable to a point.

That means some companies include extra coverage options you can't opt-out of, like PIP, rental reimbursement or accident forgiveness. You can, however, adjust coverage limits based on your needs.

While Florida’s minimum car insurance liability requirements are relatively low, it’s recommended that you purchase additional coverage to avoid paying out-of-pocket for a total loss.

The best car insurers in Florida, summed up

• Allstate
• Amica Mutual
• Farmers
• Geico
• Liberty Mutual
• Progressive
• State Farm

Additional reporting by Stephanie de Jesús