A confession to the men I’ve dated: If I ever insisted on paying my half at the end of a first date when you offered to treat, it may have been because I never wanted to see you again.
My persistence to pay was—at best—code for, “Let’s just be friends.” At worst, “Beat it.”
We all carry assumptions surrounding that first date bill and how it ought to be settled. When those expectations aren’t met, the evening could end awkwardly. She might be offended if he doesn’t let her pay; he might be annoyed if she doesn’t at least offer to chip in.
It’s an early stage financial crossroads that could make or break chances for a second date.
So, when in doubt, how should men and women best handle that first date tab? And was I right to offer to split the bill if I didn't like the guy?
Men: Offer to take the lead.
Battista and Mendez both agree that it’s generally best for men to pay on a first date. Yes, even still in 2014—a time in which, as I myself have written, women often outearn men.
But the fact of the matter is that men typically want to pay: In a poll last year conducted by LearnVest and T.D. Ameritrade, 55% of men said they thought the guy should take the check. As Mendez explains, many men feel fulfilled and accomplished when they see an opportunity to provide, even if it’s in simple ways like paying for a drink.
Perhaps more importantly, paying is a way for him to preen. “Even a guy who doesn’t make much money if he really likes you will try to impress you to the utmost that he can,” says Battista
As for women? “In my experience, 90% will be offended if a guy doesn’t offer to pay,” says Battista.
The data seems to support her claim, at least to some extent. That LearnVest poll found that 63% of women expect the guy to pay. And when researchers at Chapman University recently surveyed more than 17,000 people on the topic of first-date finances, they found that 39% of women who offered to pay said they secretly hoped the men would not let them. Meanwhile, 44% of women said they were annoyed when expected to help pay the bill.
So guys, pick up the check. It’s just a first date dance move that—more often than not—leaves each person happy and satisfied.
The exception: If she asks him out and picks the place, the experts say, she ought be prepared to settle the bill.
Women: “Practice Being Courted”
In the olden days, men routinely paid because women, generally speaking, didn't have the means to do so. But if he offers to pay nowadays, it’s not because he thinks she can’t handle it; and he's not trying to offend. He’s most likely just doing what feels instinctively appropriate in the moment.
So when he offers to pick up the tab, says Battista, "Let him. Practice being courted.”
Mendez agrees, and says letting him pay initially can be a small way of letting a relationship blossom. “It does let him know, in a subtle yet important way, that you are the kind of woman who is confident enough to accept his generosity,” he says.
This is not meant to set some sort of precedent where he pays all the time.
Remember that you can—and should—reciprocate (assuming there’s a next time). Let him pay for the first date and then offer to treat him the very next time you go out.
Or, if you’re planning to stay out after dinner, offer to grab a round of drinks or dessert at the next stop. This way you both get to practice your generosity, and it feels a bit more romantic than going halfsies all the time.
But what if she's just not that into him?
Okay, but say she decides midway through the date—or even five minutes in—that this relationship has no future. Should she accept his offer to pay, or would that be leading him to think she’s interested in seeing him again?
The experts don’t see eye to eye on this. According to Mendez, “If during the course of the first date you decide that you absolutely don’t want to see this guy again, insisting on paying for your half can help you signal more clearly that you’re not open to it.”
Battista, on the other hand, says women shouldn’t worry too much about sending mixed signals by accepting his offer to pay.
"A lot of women think, 'if he takes me out, then I owe him something,'" she says. "You don't owe him anything. If he wants to pay, either be direct [and turn him down] or just allow him to pay because that’s part of the game of dating.”
Farnoosh Torabi is a contributing editor at Money. She is the author of When She Makes More: 10 Rules for Breadwinning Women.