Should You Move Everything to Gold? A Decision Framework for Rational Investors
Precious metals, including gold, silver and platinum, have substantially outperformed the S&P 500 over the past year. Over that time, gold has gained 72% compared to the stock market index's gain of 20%.
Much of that can be attributed to traditional catalysts for the price of gold, including uncertainty around President Donald Trump's tariff policies, global conflicts and ongoing inflation, all of which have helped propel the precious metal into the spotlight.
Investors who are tired of elevated stock market volatility and low yields on fixed income assets should consider adding precious metals to their portfolios, but that doesn’t mean they should sell everything and go all-in on gold.
Precious metals can make a portfolio feel complete, but these assets aren't a panacea for financial woes. Putting too much capital into gold — or any one asset class, for that matter — can result in missing significant opportunities in other asset classes.
Here’s what investors need to know.
Understanding gold's weaknesses
Investors who want to put everything into gold already know about the precious metal’s strengths. It is an inflation hedge and a unit of value that has been around for thousands of years. Empires have come and gone, but gold has retained value through all of those civilizations.
Central banks can't print more gold, and anytime they print more of their fiat currencies, gold's value increases. It also helps that gold has outperformed the S&P 500 over the past year, as recent momentum is enough to attract many investors to an asset.
However, gold — like all assets — has its flaws. As it doesn’t provide yield, It won’t generate cash flow for retirees. You must sell gold to cover living expenses, while dividend stocks and fixed income assets can provide enough passive income without chipping away at your position.
Gold can also miss out on long-term mega trends like e-commerce, cloud computing and, — more recently — artificial intelligence. Stock pickers who find the right companies can outperform gold by vast margins.
Zooming out: historical precious metal performances
It’s easy to forget about an asset's historical shortcomings when it has substantial momentum. Investors also tend to forget how well an asset has historically performed when it is in the middle of a slump.
Although gold has outpaced the S&P 500 over the past year, that wasn't always the case. For instance, gold dropped by more than 25% in 2013, while the S&P 500 rallied by roughly 30% that year. This is one of several examples when gold trailed the stock market over a long period of time.
Precious metals can also overheat during their big runs and leave new investors holding the bag. Silver provided an excellent case study of this scenario earlier this year. The precious metal has been surging over several months due to scarcity and high demand, outperforming both stocks and gold in 2026. But the asset reached a breaking point on Jan. 30 and crashed by more than 30%. It’s still ahead of the S&P 500 on the year, but investors who bought silver right before the big drop have been trailing the stock market.
Gold also became a hit commodity last year during Trump's roll-out of global tariffs. But those trade policies actually created an ideal buying opportunity for equities when the market bottomed last April. While some investors panicked and sold high-quality stocks, those prices rebounded by the end of the year. Selling stocks at the bottom proved to be a costly mistake, even for investors who used those proceeds to buy gold.
It's better to buy gold and other assets before uncertainty strikes. Calmer, bullish economic cycles present good opportunities to accumulate gold before the next conflict, tariff or other malefactor rattles investors.
How gold fits into a portfolio
As previously mentioned, all assets have their strengths and weaknesses. While gold's strengths have been notable in recent years, that doesn't mean you should go all-in on this asset. However, that doesn’t suggest staying on the sidelines is the right choice either.
The proper balance varies for each person, depending on their risk tolerance and long-term financial goals. Young investors have more time to wait for reliable stocks to regain momentum. They can also afford to take additional risk since they won't retire for multiple decades. Investing serves as a means to an end. Growing your money now gives you more choices and can result in a seamless retirement, and equities offer the highest growth potential.
But older investors who are ready to tap into their nest eggs and don’t have as much time to recover from short-term market corrections. These investors usually allocate more capital to gold and fixed income assets to mitigate risk, as the precious metal has long been considered a store of value and can grow in a tax-advantaged gold IRA.
It's also important to consider why you want to buy gold. Many people accumulate gold when stocks perform poorly. They want to end the stock losses, exit the equity markets and put the money in an inflation hedge like gold.
This mentality can lead to more losses since investors often act on these thoughts deep into corrections that are bound to fix themselves eventually. These types of investors end up selling stocks at low prices and buying gold at high prices.
It makes more sense to buy gold as a long-term piece of your portfolio while ignoring market headlines. A stock market correction should not be your motivation to buy gold. Any buy or sell order for any asset should align with your financial goals and risk tolerance.
Gold should not replace stocks and fixed income. However, it offers a good middle ground that can rally when other asset classes falter since it — like other alternative assets — is generally uncorrelated with the stock market.
Stone-hard wealth protection
