Why Many Gold IRA Companies Lose Investor Trust (and What to Look for Instead)

Gold individual retirement accounts (IRAs) combine precious metal investing with tax-advantaged retirement planning. And while it sounds like a simple premise with numerous benefits, many gold IRA companies have lost investors’ trust.

That’s something that is hard to gain in any industry, but there are a few ways that gold IRAs erode goodwill. Luckily, some gold IRA providers are trustworthy, but knowing how to identify the ones that are not can help investors avoid unpromising options.

Hidden fees and excessive markups

No matter the industry, each of them has different ways it can lose the trust of its customers. For financial institutions, that can be the result of charging high costs. For instance, paying a 30% markup on a collectible coin may be all it takes to lose trust in a gold IRA provider. High storage fees can also disgruntle investors as their total returns deteriorate.

While some gold IRAs have competitive fees, a few companies with aggressive fees can distort the precious metals industry. It doesn’t help that gold IRAs are also up against traditional equity IRAs that let investors trade stocks and funds often at lower costs. So a 30% mark-up on a collectible coin or a 10% markup on a gold bar’s spot price can make other IRAs more attractive.

That problem can be compounded for investors who don’t look at fee schedules when comparing gold IRAs. A fee schedule reveals all of the fees and how much they cost. Looking at fee schedules can help investors distinguish reputable gold IRAs from the bad ones, but people who don’t look at these schedules risk getting involved with less reputable providers.

Aggressive sales tactics

Gold IRA companies can also lose trust by resorting to aggressive sales tactics that pressure investors into creating accounts instead of clearly laying out the pros and cons of these investments accounts.

Aggressive sales strategies may include offering time-sensitive bonuses for anyone who puts money into their gold IRA within a 24-hour window or warning that the global economy is about to collapse and that gold is the only viable solution to preserving their wealth.

While gold acts as a hedge against inflation and uncertainty, gold IRA companies that constantly push worst-case scenarios risk losing out on potential customers. Those actions also create more obstacles for gold IRA companies that focus on low fees, competitive offerings and honest assessments about how much gold makes sense for someone’s portfolio.

Some sellers also emphasize their gold and silver coins that have higher markups than regular bars. Aggressive sales tactics combined with focusing on assets that generate the most profit for gold IRA companies at the expense of investors is not a winning long-term strategy.

The inability to store gold at home

Many gold investors who buy physical precious metals want to store them at home. That’s the main reason they go through the process of buying these metals instead of just buying an exchange-traded fund, or ETF, that tracks the price of gold.

Many of these same investors may be displeased to hear that the IRS doesn’t let them store physical gold that they buy within their IRAs. A third party is responsible for storing the gold on your behalf if you want it to qualify for a gold IRA. You can eventually have the gold shipped to you when you withdraw it from your IRA, but you don’t get control over your gold in the short run.

Few gold IRA companies mention this fact. Some may avoid sharing this information because it weakens their core offering, while other gold IRA companies assume that potential customers already know that information.

Weak or no buyback policies

Too many unpleasant surprises add up, and it’s good to look for gold IRAs that are upfront about fees, IRS rules and buyback policies. That last one is important since gold IRAs can offer extra liquidity in an otherwise low-liquidity asset.

While buyback policies sound good, some firms have policies that make it financially unattractive. For instance, some buyback policies only require a 1% fee, but some gold IRAs have buyback policies that get as high as 30%.

You are not locked into a buyback policy if you don’t like it. For instance, investors can sell their gold to other dealers or transfer it to a different broker. However, an expensive buyback policy can rub investors the wrong way.

Accumulating gold while reducing taxes: the right way

Companies with too many red flags can discourage investors from pursuing gold IRAs that have a bunch of green flags. While most people focus on stocks, gold and other precious metals will further diversify your portfolio and make your nest egg less vulnerable to stock market corrections.

It’s worth the effort to compare gold IRAs, assess fee schedules and determine which one aligns with your long-term goals. Enjoying tax benefits in a gold IRA offers multiple opportunities to grow your net worth in a way that is generally uncorrelated with the stock market. Buying and holding gold in the long run will make trading fees and the one-time setup fee less relevant over time.

More from Money:

Best Gold IRA Companies

Best Online Gold Dealers

How to Buy Gold