Gold IRA Fees, Spreads and Red Flags: What ‘Transparent’ Should Actually Mean

Gold individual retirement accounts (IRAs) are a great way for you to accumulate precious metals in a tax-advantaged account. But investors who aren’t careful can end up with unpleasant surprises: Some gold IRAs produce much lower returns than expected because fees silently chip away at the value of the physical metals.

While every gold IRA provider touts themselves as being transparent, some are more transparent than others. That transparency goes a long way in understanding fee schedules and spreads, both of which significantly contribute to the true cost of a gold IRA.

Here’s what you need to know about gold IRA fees and spreads, as well as how to spot red flags so you determine if it’s worth putting your money into these tax-advantaged retirement accounts.

Common gold IRA fees

Every gold IRA has fees, and prospective customers can request fee schedules to see how much they will actually have to pay for the account. The fee schedule lists every expense you will incur and often includes setup fees, trading fees, storage fees and insurance.

For example, it’s common for gold IRAs to charge $50 to $200 for a one-time setup fee. Some gold IRAs don’t charge this fee but may have more expensive fees in other categories.

Comparing multiple fee schedules can help you gauge which gold IRAs offer the best deals. Transparency for gold IRA fees is straightforward, and the companies offering these types of retirement accounts should make their fee schedules easy for people to locate on their websites. If you have to do some digging to find the fee schedule, it may be a red flag.

While you can request a fee schedule from any gold IRA provider, the fact that those companies make fee schedules difficult to find may be a sign that they charge higher fees than their competitors.

How gold spreads can affect returns

Every financial asset has a spread that reflects the difference between how much it costs to buy and how much you receive for selling an asset. Brokerage firms have bid-ask spreads that let them realize small profits with every buy and sell order. Similarly, gold IRAs also participate in this opportunity.

Most gold IRAs have spreads that range from 1% to 2% for standard gold bars, while the spreads for popular coins can be a bit higher. A 1% spread means that if you spend $1,000 on gold, you must pay the IRA provider $10 to cover the spread. That’s before any other ongoing fees.

Some IRA providers present spreads as a fixed amount of dollars above the spot price, such as an extra $3.50 on top of the current — or spot — price of gold. That could result in a lower percentage fee if gold prices are high.

You should only work with a gold IRA provider that lists its spreads on its fee schedule. Otherwise, spreads can turn into a costly hidden fee that can erode your total returns.

Identifying red flags in the gold IRA industry

Every industry has its risks, and with some, it’s easier to spot the red flags. Knowing what to avoid in the gold IRA industry can help you make smarter decisions with their investment products.

One of the most common red flags is aggressive sales tactics that often involve a fake sense of urgency. While gold can act as a hedge against inflation and market uncertainty, an aggressive seller may claim that the dollar is about to collapse and buying gold immediately is your only hope to preserve your nest egg. Hyperbolic extremes can cause people to open gold IRAs without comparing accounts and considering the fees.

It's also important to vet gold IRA providers by reading their online reviews, checking their Better Business Bureau scores and comparing fee schedules. You should avoid companies with poor reviews, numerous complaints and regulatory mishaps. Companies that have been around for many years or new firms that are led by seasoned precious metal industry experts tend to be the most promising gold IRA providers.

If you go beyond standard bars and opt to buy coins, you will have to do some additional research. Some gold and silver coins have absurd markups that can require a 20% return just to break even. It’s good to avoid sellers that aggressively push coins in order to bolster their sales. Collectible coins are the worst offenders and have some of the highest markups in the industry — make sure you look for coins issued by reputable, respected mints.

How the gold IRA industry can approach transparency

Transparency comes down to informing potential investors about every possible cost, from insurance and storage fees to spreads and account-opening expenses. Some gold IRAs have complex fee schedules by design that make it difficult to spot some of the most egregious costs that you will incur if you contribute to one of their plans. The fee schedule should be neatly organized and easily accessible on the company’s website.

However, transparency alone isn’t enough to win over investors. Being transparent about a 5% transaction fee on all gold trades will be a major deterrent, even if it is clearly labeled on the fee schedule. Gold IRA providers should strive to offer competitive fees and look for ways to reduce their existing fees.

While gold IRAs can’t eliminate all of their fees, they can look for opportunities to narrow the expenses that investors incur from their retirement plans. This decision can attract more people to gold IRAs and potentially be lucrative for the companies providing the accounts.

More from Money:

Best Gold IRA Companies

Best Online Gold Dealers

How to Buy Gold