Robert Zimmer, president, University of Chicago, speaks during a panel discussion,  2012: The Path to the Presidency , at the University of Chicago in Chicago on Thursday, Jan. 19, 2012.
Nam Y. Huh—AP

What's the relationship between college presidents' pay and the value their schools deliver to students?

Not much, it seems.

That's what we discovered when we compared Money's just-released 2015 Best Colleges rankings, which evaluate schools on 21 measures of educational quality, affordability, and career earnings, with the latest available data on private college presidents' compensation, published by the Chronicle of Higher Education. The latter numbers are from 2012, but in all likelihood the salary figures have only gone up since then.

At a time when parents and students scrape to find the money for college, or go deep into debt to afford it, 36 private college presidents brought home more than $1 million each. Nearly 150 college presidents received more than $400,000, making them better paid than the president of the United States.

View Sample

Among the findings:

  • The highest paid college president, Shirley Ann Jackson of Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, took home a base salary of $945,000 plus another $276,474 in bonuses, $31,874 in nontaxable benefits, and $5.8 million in deferred compensation, for a stunning $7.1 million in total. That works out to more than $1,000 per student at her school. And where does her school fall in our value rankings? A good but not spectacular 147.
  • In second place for total compensation was Quinnipiac University's John L. Lahey, whose take that year was close to $3.8 million. You'll find his school further down our rankings, at 246.
  • Coming in at No. 5 on the highest paid list was Charles R. Middleton, then president of Roosevelt University in Chicago, whose total compensation was nearly $1.8 million. You won't find his school in our rankings at all; its six-year graduation rate was too low to make the cut.

In fact, of the top 10 schools in Money's value rankings of 736 colleges, only one shows up in the list of 10 highest paid presidents: the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, which we rated No. 3. Its then-president, Susan Hockfield, earned a total compensation package of about $1.7 million, putting her in sixth place for pay.

Here are the 10 highest paid presidents of private colleges, based on the Chronicle of Higher Education data, along with how their schools did in Money's latest rankings. And to see how much their counterparts at public colleges are making, check out this earlier report.